Scalia's gestural language

is eloquent. But he says it doesn't mean anything. OK, I didn't grow up in suburban New York for nothing. Accompanying the gesture, Tony is said to have let loose, "To my critics, I say 'Vafancull-" umm yes indeed, that is a Supreme Court justice speaking to the Press. It's TONY SCALIA, not TONY SOPRANO.
Now, I happen to know a lot of senstive, anti-racist "type" who believe that "stereotyping" of people is the worst thing a citizen of the world can do. We are all types -- to understand or identify the type is to be able to see the hardened, objective, authoritarian remnants of inculcation both in others and ourselves -- we struggle with it, we may even occasionally rise above it. But we can not destroy typology as destiny.
We must refuse the humanist pablum of "We are all different." Different from what? For Adorno, most of us have remained "types" and have not attained anything even like individualism, or at least, in the case of everyone, our particularism is shot through by typology -- the libidinally blocked nerd, the angry young man, Jewish American Princess, the Southern beauty queen, the Asian good girl -- so even as Hollywood narratives glorify everything on the level of the individual, many of us are not individuated enough to take a critical view of the sedimentation of the type within, which are like veins in marble, or swirls in your chocolate swirl in your creamy cheesecake.
Scalia is a type -- vulgar, Sicilian, crypto-Fascist, Mafioso-like, strong man, Supreme Court justice who believes himself above the law -- oh, am I being anti-Italian? Only if you think "tolerance" obviates critique! Fall into your own stereotype and you will find that that is the place where you were prepared for regression, repressive desublimation, absolute submission to authority and the use of violence (against or for yourself!)


















4 Comments:
wrong on both counts. hollywood only deals in types. no individuals there, only archtypal narratives with their jungian default positions. and to stereotype is not being realist, it is potentially - as evident in your characterization of scalia - unnecessarily superficial and actionable. he may or may not be sicilian or vulgar or mafioso - it's certainly not from the picture that one would know. there is no video, and the gesture is not all that vulgar - it's just a kind of "I don't care".
Hollywood deals in narrativized individuality -- every hero or heroine falls and rises alone -- there is no collectivism involved here -- and they process them through the archetypal image of the hero.
So you're actually not reading film as a temporal medium when you insist upon Hollywood's 'default' position.
I'm not affirming stereotyping as a default position, only criticizing anti-stereotyping as a kind of politics, which it isn't.
Also you're reading my description of vulgarity as totally negative and it's not. Vulgarity has a kind of lifeblood and vitality and to denounce something as vulgar is to recognize that! And why do you think he would want to sue me? He's not into identity politics. He can take it on his quite substantial chin.
anonymous - please, visit Sicily and order a pasta dish and accompanying side salad in a sidewalk cafe. When asked which dressing you would like with your salad, repeat Scalia's gesture and say "Vafancul" (va fan cul = "go f*ck yourself" [Ital., vulgar] from Va fan cul, "go do [the] anus"); of course if it actually means "I don't care" then you would have nothing to worry about and the waiter will select an appropriate dressing for your salad. Should you come down with a stomach ailment from eating that salad, well, vafancul.
Thanks Yearning Heart!
I appreciate the support on this issue!
Let me recommend to anonymous to try out his Italian closer to home, let's say in the declining Italian neighorhoods of Little Italy or Brooklyn. Try to get a slice in one of the pizzerias around and when asked "Would you like thin crust or Sicilian style?" say "Vafancullo" because you don't care.
And you'll see why I won't be taking Italian lessons from you!
Post a Comment
<< Home